
In this article
No pair of shorts is as polarizing as jean shorts. For some, they’re dreadfully uncomfortable (“Abolish Jean Shorts” reads a recent headline from our friends over at the Cut), while for others, they’re as essential to summer dressing as a pair of sandals. The return of jorts has unsettled the debate even further. I’m not sure where I stood before starting to write this guide, but after hearing from several enthusiasts about why they love their jean shorts, I’m pretty sure those who aren’t fans just haven’t found the right ones yet. Here, you’ll find all sorts — cutoffs, longline, and low-slung jean styles — recommended by those who are most opinionated about them, including newsletter writers, brand founders, stylists, and Strategist staffers. And if you’re looking for more of our denim coverage, we have guides to mom jeans and jean jackets as well.
Update on August 19, 2024: Updated prices and checked stock for all products.
What we’re looking for
Sizes
Jean shorts are sized according to waist measurements (for example: 25, 26, 27) or numbered beginning at zero (on occasion, double-zero). You should be double checking size charts — a size 28 in a brand could be a size 2 in another.
As with my other fashion coverage, I wanted this list to be as size-inclusive as possible and included pairs available in a range of sizes. If one of our enthusiasts had sizing suggestions for a pair (say, sizing up), I made sure to mention that, too.
Rise
So you know where a jean short will sit on your waist, pay close attention to the rise. A rise that’s closer to 11 inches (and above) is thought to be high-waisted, while one that’s closer to the ten-inch mark is more of a mid-rise and somewhere between seven to nine inches is a low rise.
Inseam
Inseam lengths for jean shorts are often odd numbered — three inches, five inches, seven inches and so on. Generally, a three-inch inseam is a cutoff, while a nine-inch inseam would be called long.
Stretch
Almost all of the jean shorts here are made from non-stretch denim, or 100 percent cotton. And while a fabric with one percent stretch — elastane, spandex, or Lycra — may not seem like that much of a difference, it can make a jean short feel broken-in from the beginning. A good rule of thumb is not to go over 2 percent stretch so there’s less of a chance for overstretching. I’ve noted whether a jean short is non-stretch or stretch with the exact fabric composition in parentheses.
Price
To feature everything from the budget friendly to the splurgeworthy, I tagged each jean short as either $ (under $75), $$ ($75 to $150), or $$$ (over $150).
Best overall jean shorts for women
Sizes: 22–34 | Rise: 11.25 inches | Inseam: 2.5 inches | Stretch: Non-stretch (100 percent cotton) | Price: $$
If you hear the words jean shorts, you might imagine a pair like Agolde’s Parker short. It’s the Goldilocks ideal of a cutoff — well fitting and short but not too short — that has even earned a place in our Womenswear 100. They have a loyal following, including Caroline Maguire, senior fashion director at Shopbop, and Hallie Abrams, a.k.a the Wardrobe Consultant. Abrams credits this to their shape, which isn’t too tight through the hips and allows the kind of easy movement (and breathing room) you’ll want on hot days. Business student Laura Naparstek agrees, adding that she hasn’t been able to re-create the shorts’ triangular silhouette when trying (vainly) to DIY her own cutoffs for years.
These shorts are made from a non-stretch denim that takes a few wears to break in but then will “get better (and softer) with each wear,” says Kate Sokolov, co-founder of Social Goods. At almost $150, they’re not exactly cheap for a pair of jean shorts, but Strategist senior editor Hilary Reid, who bought her pair four years ago, says they’re worth every penny. “I spent probably twice as much of the cost of these trying out other pairs of jean shorts that I hated after a few wears,” she says. “These were absolutely worth the splurge — they’re really the only pair of denim shorts you’ll ever need.” The Parker is available in a whole host of washes, and there’s a “long” version of the shorts with a four-inch inseam.
Best (less expensive) overall jean shorts
Sizes: 23–34 (plus sizes 14–24 here) | Rise: 10.5 inches | Inseam: 7.5 inches | Stretch: Non-stretch (100 percent cotton) | Price: $
Those who love their Levi’s will usually turn the jeans into jean shorts. Catbird’s Rony Vardi cuts up her Ribcages, while editor Mallory Rice sources some secondhand from a Minnesota shop and designer Susan Alexandra buys them off eBay two sizes too big to “emanate insouciance.” You don’t have to go through all that trouble, though, as Levi’s makes many shorts inspired by its jeans. The ’90s edition of the 501s — the first true-blue jean — is one of them. It’s meant to look loose, and it has a longer inseam. Café Forgot co-founder Lucy Weisner likes the fit on them more than the original 501s. “They’re definitely a little looser in the legs,” she says, and suggests sizing up for something even slouchier. “They’re great for strolling around the city on a hot summer day,” Weisner tells me.
Best jean shorts for petite women
Sizes: 22–33 | Rise: 11.5 inches | Inseam: five inches | Stretch: Non-stretch (100 percent cotton) | Price: $$$
When you’re shopping for shorts as a petite person, it’s all about the inseam. I’m petite myself, and I’d say a two- to three-inch inseam gets you a pair of proper shortie-shorts. But if you’re looking for a short that’s on the longer — but not too long — side, the Clove shorts from AG (another denim-maker seen all over our archives) won’t fall past your knees. The five-inch inseam is just right on Strategist writer Arielle Avila’s five-foot-one frame. Avila told me the shorts hit right about mid-thigh, and even as she has retired most of her jorts, these jorts “look relaxed without trying to be a trendy Bermuda.” They’re baggier than the tight-fitting jean shorts of her past, yet they “don’t get bunched up in the crotch,” she adds. “I feel like I’ve always had to sacrifice comfort when I wear jorts, but these are broken-in out of the box.” The pair are the priciest I heard about, but details like distressed edges, a frayed hem, and fading on the denim make them worth the price.
Best jean shorts for tall women
Sizes: 23–34 | Rise: 11.25 inches | Inseam: 4.5 inches | Stretch: Non-stretch (100 percent cotton) | Price: $$$
The advice that artist Melly Wirtes — who’s six-foot-two — gives when shopping for shorts as an especially tall woman is to find a four-inch (or close to that) inseam. “For me, under four inches leads to wedgies and the not-oft-discussed phenomenon of bare butt contact on scorching-hot park benches and café chairs and sweating on hot taxi seats,” she explains. The Annabelle short from Citizens of Humanity clocks in at close to four inches and is long enough for Wirtes’s legs. It’s one of the only jean shorts she has worn for two summers in a row now, a staple of her hot-weather wardrobe. These “old-faithful cutoffs are as classic a summer pastime as baseball,” she says.
Best curve-fit jean shorts
Sizes: 23–37 | Rise: Not listed | Inseam: five inches | Stretch: Stretch (99 percent cotton, 1 percent elastane) | Price: $
Abercrombie’s Curve Love cuts (which are separate from its “straight” sizes) are designed with room through the hips and thighs so there’s less chance of waist gapping. The line’s Dad Short has some stretch (thanks to elastane) that gives them a good looseness, according to content creator Marielle Elizabeth. As someone with thicker thighs, she says the longer length helps her with thigh chafing and ensures that she doesn’t have to constantly tug these down while she’s out and about. Elizabeth told me she sized up so the shorts would be more comfortable, and they are just that. “I’m talking going on an all-day road trip comfortable,” she says. After purchasing her first pair last summer, she picked up a second and third this year. Abercrombie also sells a non-curve version, which former Strategist writer Latifah Miles dedicated an ode to. At five-foot-ten, Miles was “able to confidently sit down and stand up without worrying about a rogue butt cheek peeking out from the bottom.”
Best super-high-waisted jean shorts
Sizes: 23–34 | Rise: 11.8 inches | Inseam: 6.7 inches | Stretch: Stretch (79 percent cotton, 21 percent Lyocell) | Price: $$
The Super Mirage Short from Rolla’s — an Australian brand known for making butt-hugging jeans — has the highest rise, at almost 12 inches, of any of the jean shorts here. (For reference: The Ribcages, our pick for the best super-high-waisted jeans, have a rise of 12 inches.) The pair cinches in Strategist writer Katherine Gillespie’s waist and then widens comfortably around the thighs. Lengthwise, “they’re definitely not participating in the Zoomer jort trend, nor are they a Daisy Duke short-short.” There’s a ’70s, “very Birkin” quality to them, she says. Gillespie even wore them on a recent vacation to Marseille, where they were ideal for beach days.
Another short of note that has some flare: & Other Stories High-Waist Denim Shorts. Elizabeth Cardinal Tamkin, author of the newsletter Corner Booth and content director at Kule, likes how nondescript they are with no label or much detailing on the pocket. “People always ask me where I got them, assuming I scored a vintage prize,” she says.
Best low-slung jean shorts
Sizes: 24–35 | Rise: 10.375 inches | Inseam: four inches | Stretch: Non-stretch (95 percent cotton, 5 percent recycled cotton) | Price: $
Another pair Wirtes recommends is the Low Rise Stride from Gap. This style sits slightly lower on the waist than others on this list, though at 10.375 inches, the rise is still higher than what I would technically call low rise. That said, they’re an “unfussy cutoff that has a cool, downtown, not-trying-too-hard” look,” she says. Wirtes went for the shorts in the “tall” fit, with the inseam the same across the board. She sized up for a fit that sits right at her hips.
Best longline jean short
Sizes: 23–37 | Rise: 11.25 inches | Inseam: nine inches | Stretch: Non-stretch (100 percent cotton) | Price: $
The longest shorts on this list, this J.Crew pair has a nine-inch inseam, which means the hem hits closer to the knee than on most pairs. For stylist Leah Adicoff, who is six feet tall, the pair falls a little longer than mid-thigh, and she describes it as having “a little kick-out, and an A-line shape, which is really flattering.” The shorts also have front pleating, reminiscent of what you would see on a traditional trouser, which makes them feel dressed up. The denim has some give, and the shorts are “structured and sturdy enough to hold their shape,” Adicoff adds.
[Editor’s note: Some sizes are currently sold out, but you can sign up to be emailed when yours is back in stock.]
Some more shorts we’ve written about
Our experts
• Hallie Abrams, a.k.a the Wardrobe Consultant
• Leah Adicoff, stylist
• Susan Alexandra, designer
• Arielle Avila, Strategist writer
• Marielle Elizabeth, content creator
• Katherine Gillespie, Strategist writer
• Laura Naparstek, business student
• Latifah Miles, former Strategist writer
• Hilary Reid, Strategist senior editor
• Mallory Rice, editor
• Kate Sokolov, co-founder of Social Goods
• Elizabeth Cardinal Tamkin, author of the newsletter Corner Booth and content director at Kule
• Rony Vardi, Catbird founder
• Lucy Weisner, Café Forgot co-founder
• Melly Wirtes, artist
The Strategist is designed to surface useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Every product is independently selected by our team of editors, whom you can read about here. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.